Waterfront Living & Quiet Subdivisions: 4 Best Neighborhoods in Toms River

Toms River Best Neighborhoods

Are you getting ready to move to Toms River? You're about to become a resident of one of the most beautiful areas on the Jersey Shore. The best neighborhoods in Toms River each offer something every Ocean County home buyer can appreciate. From waterfront homes with private boat docks to spacious single-family homes on quiet culs-de-sac, the best real estate in Toms River is easy to find when you know where to start your search.

Search Toms River Homes for Sale.

Shelter Cove

Shelter Cove sits along Barnegat Bay, centered on Bay Avenue east of Fischer Boulevard. The community was first established in the late 1950s but continues to develop even today, with homes being extensively renovated or replaced. One of the biggest highlights is Shelter Cove Park, which includes green space, sports facilities, a small bay beach, and a playground.

Homes in Shelter Cove are typically all single-family detached properties but can range widely in size, style, and price. On the low end, more modestly sized or older homes can sell from the high $200,000s to the mid-$300,000s. Most list from the mid-$400,000s to around a half-million, generally offering two or three bedrooms spread over 1,200-2,000 square feet. However, Shelter Cove's spacious, luxury waterfront properties can stretch well into the millions, reaching as high as $3-4 million.

Walking trails within the neighborhood also connect to nearby Cattus Island County Park, an even more expansive and less developed waterfront green space. It's also convenient to Thomas A. Mathis Bridge, allowing residents to reach some of the Garden State's best beaches in only a few minutes, like Seaside Heights and Lavallette. Plus, everyday shopping and popular restaurants like Four Seasons Diner occupy retail areas just outside the neighborhood.

Shelter Cove Amenities

  • Barnegat Bay waterfront access
  • Shelter Cove Park
  • Convenient to Cattus Island County Park
  • Close to shopping, beach access
  • VCA Fischer Animal Hospital

Snug Harbor

Another Toms River community that takes its name from the water feature it borders, Snug Harbor offers the advantage of direct waterfront living for nearly every resident, thanks to its extensive canal network. This makes it a perfect neighborhood for boaters and others who like to get out on the water, which they can do right from their own backyards! Meanwhile, the dead-end or cul-de-sac streets help reduce traffic and allow residents to get to know their neighbors.

Snug Harbor homes are single-family detached properties, ranging from quaint one-story cottages to massive, multi-level new-construction mansions. Some can be found as low as the mid-$600,000s, with average homes selling in the high six figures to around $1.25 million. Top properties can reach the $1.5-3 million range, particularly for those directly on the bay instead of a canal. If you're looking for luxury homes in Toms River, these canal-front estates might just fit the bill.

Residents love to explore the adjacent Cattus Island County Park, a 530-acre preserve with seven miles of trails winding through forest and coastal ecosystems, including some fantastic bay views and educational resources at the Cooper Environmental Center. It's also not far from Ocean County College for those who want to take a course or earn a new degree.

Snug Harbor Amenities

  • Private docks/water access
  • Cattus Island County Park
  • Toms River Township Pool
  • Convenient to Fischer Boulevard shopping/services

Twin Oaks

Where are the Best Neighborhoods in Toms River, NJ?

Twin Oaks offers some of Toms Rivers's best-value homes in this quiet, almost entirely residential inland community. Housing in Twin Oaks consists of single-family detached homes available in both single- and two-story styles. Most include two to four bedrooms and 1,600-2,600 square feet of living space, built on lots of a third of an acre or more. They can be found for as low as the low $300,000s. The majority of homes sell from the mid-$400,000s to around $600,000.

Thanks to the neighborhood's coveted central location, owners have nearly everything Toms River has to offer right at their fingertips. It's located just north of Ocean County Route 571, just east of the Ocean County Mall. This makes it an excellent location for shoppers, who can take advantage of dozens of stores, restaurants, and entertainment options in other smaller retail complexes. Residents are also just a few minutes drive from downtown Toms River, a quaint stretch of local shops, restaurants, bars, coffee shops, and more, like Water Street Bar & Grille, Battle River Brewing, and Bubby's Beanery. There's also plenty of nearby green space, including Skyview Park and Bay Lea Park, home to one of the most popular Ocean County golf courses.

Twin Oaks Amenities

  • Skyview Park
  • Convenient to Ocean County Mall, Route 37, downtown Toms River
  • Bey Lea Park and Golf Course

Green Island

Green Island is another waterfront community in northeastern Toms River. The community was first established in 1945 and has an active neighborhood organization, hosting holiday events, game nights, fireworks, and more. It also maintains the small community beach (Point Beach), allowing residents to enjoy Barnegat Bay without leaving their neighborhood. While the area itself is almost entirely residential, a convenient selection of shops, restaurants, and other services can be found a short drive away along Hooper Avenue.

Homes on Green Island are a diverse mix of single-family detached properties, ranging from affordable to luxury, though most range from three to five bedrooms. On the low end, some more modestly sized or older single-story homes around 1,000 square feet can sell from the mid-to-high $300,000s. Green Island's most upscale properties are sprawling multi-story homes that can often sell for up to $1.25 million. A wide variety of options are available in between. Thanks to the unique community design, many homes back onto manmade canals (or the bay itself), providing a place to dock a boat or enjoy the water behind their homes.

Green Island Amenities

  • Extensive Barnegat Bay waterfront
  • Private canals
  • Point Beach
  • Community events
  • Kettle Creek Marina

Discover the Best Places to Live in Tom's River

Living in one of the best neighborhoods makes enjoying everything this community offers easy. From waterfront homes to easy access to Ocean County beaches, the best places to live in Toms River promise the Jersey Shore lifestyle you've been waiting for. Which neighborhood has your dream home?

Thinking about a move to Toms River? Contact The Dekanski Home Selling Team of RE/MAX 1st Advantage with New Jersey Real Estate Network at (800) 691-0485 to reach our real estate experts who can help you find your dream home in Toms River.

Buying or Selling
a Toms River Home?

Work With the #1 Real Estate Team in New Jersey Now!

Robert Dekanski

Post a Comment